![]() Scientists have only studied the world in various ways; the point is to change it. ....Marx |
RADICAL PEDAGOGY:
Sponsored by the Red Feather Institute for Advanced Studies in Sociology |
| by TR Young | for Samantha Speaks |
Dear SS: Here is two-dimensional set of ideas about how to teach
environmental marxism to students whom, I would presume don't want
to hear too much critique of capitalism...especially from a Marxist
perspective:
Teaching Outline:
1. Start off listing the many benefits of capitalism as economic system:
a. it is the most productive in human history
b. it is the most flexible
c. it is the most innovative
d. it drives the best knowledge system ever
seen
e. it tends to destroy ancient systems of
privilege:
ethnic, racial, gender
and religious...when it cannot
use such divisions for
lower wages and political legitimacy.
f...and more if you use an Handout...
2. Show how each of these advantages is matched with problems for
the environment...make the general point that all environmental
questions are mediated by the quest for profit...this means that:
a. air, water and soil is used as a dump for
waste materials
of factories, plants,
agro-business, energy, mining and
mills as costs of
production are transferred to the
environment
b. raw materials: lumber, oil, metals and
minerals are extracted
in the fastest, least
costly, most aggressive ways possible.
The very productivity
of capitalism requires super-exploit-
ation of resources.
c. in Authoritarian states, pollution is
absorbed by the bodies
of the poor; especially
nursing women and their infant
children.
in Democratic states, costs of pollution
control and clean-up
is transferred...via taxes...to workers,
consumers and future
tax payers via state
debt.
d. in Core Democratic countries, environmental
groups tend to
transfer pollution to
3rd World countries as environmental
laws protect more and
more land, more and more people and
more and more products
in Core Capitalist Countries.
e. in all countries, capitalists try to buy the
political
process; this subverts
all efforts to protect the environ-
ment.
f. the knowledge process tends to be organized
to seek low-cost
and technical solutions
to environmental problems after the
fact rather than
re-organizing production to prevent pollution.
2. Teaching devices:
1. Ask five students to bring trash to class; define the last three
rows as the under-class and dump the trash
where they sit.
tie this to the export of enironmental problems
from the rich
to the poor; from rich countries to poor
countries.
2. give Handouts on Controlling Pollution to and only to the first
two rows...after you define them as Consultants
to Corporations
tie this to the distortion of the knowledge
process and the
creation of an army of intellectuals on the
payroll of capital.
3. Ask students how many have five or more:
a. radios in their home
b. television sets in
their home
c. cars in their family
how many have:
a. more than 10 pairs
of shoes
b. more than 5 pair of
jeans
c. more than 10
tee-shirts.
tie all this to the Colonization of Desire and
the creation
of False Needs after Marcuse.
4. Be creative, have fun and clean up after your self.
and
let me know what you do, TR
Note on this mini-syllabus: Samatha Speaks posted the following note on
the socgrad
network...the outline above is my reply:
>Hello, I'm guest teaching a one-hour class of environmental marxism.
>Does anyone have any good examples of how they get students interested and
>involved in the topic?
>
>
>Thank you for the assistance
>
>Samantha Speaks